Mythbusters: Charmed 2 Death?

Girl Scout badges, Girl Scout History Project
Studio 2B logo

My recent post on the unpopular Girl Scout Studio 2B program revived an old tale about the program’s signature charms being recalled due to high led content.

I’d heard the story myself and decided to investigate.

It turns out that Girl Scouts of the USA did, in fact, recall a charm in November 2007.

According the press release announcing the recall (see below), the specific issue related to the lead content of one paint color of one charm, not the metal itself. Specifically:

Current standards indicate that metal and paint objects for children under age six must be under 600ppm, and while the charm was not an age-specific activity award, GSUSA has made the recall of this accessory.

GSUSA Press Release, November 17, 2007.

The charm in question appeared in the 2007 Girl Scout Catalog, which described it as “perfect for keyrings, backpacks or totes.”

Girl Scout badges, Girl Scout History Project
2007 Girl Scout Catalog, page 9

How Rumors Get Started

It is easy to see how this myth arose. Studio 2B seemed to be blamed for everything else.

The Studio 2B program began switching from charms to patches the following year, making it easy to assume they were eliminated due to their lead content–not their program content.

For all of Studio 2B’s flaws, at least it wasn’t lethal.

©2021 Ann Robertson, writer, editor, and Girl Scout historian

Here is the full press release:

Girl Scout badges, Girl Scout History Project

One thought on “Mythbusters: Charmed 2 Death?

  1. The charm in question was not a Studio2b recognition award, it was a general item. Makes one wonder what other items were “recalled” or discontinued for safety sake over the decades.

    Thanks Ann for the deeper look and myth busting.

Leave a Reply